Wednesday, September 17, 2014

Europeans drawn from three 'tribes'

The modern European gene pool was formed when three ancient populations mixed with one another within the last 7,000 years, Nature journal reports.

Blue-eyed, swarthy hunters mingled with brown-eyed, pale skinned farmers as the latter swept into Europe from the Near East.

But another, mysterious population with Siberian affinities also contributed to the genetic landscape of the continent.

The findings are based analysis of the genomes of nine ancient Europeans.

Agriculture originated in the Near East - in modern Syria, Iraq and Israel - before expanding into Europe around 7,500 years ago.

'Start Quote

It really does look like the indigenous West European hunter gatherers had this striking combination of dark skin and blue eyes that doesn't exist any more'

End Quote Prof David Reich Harvard Medical School

Multiple lines of evidence suggested this new way of life was spread not just via the exchange of ideas, but by a wave of migrants, who interbred with the indigenous European hunter-gatherers they encountered on the way.

But assumptions about European origins were based largely on the genetic patterns of living people. The science of analysing genomic DNA from ancient bones has put some of the prevailing theories to the test, throwing up a few surprises.

Genomic DNA contains the biochemical instructions for building a human, and resides within the nucleus of our cells.

In the new paper, Prof David Reich from the Harvard Medical School and colleagues studied the genomes of seven hunter-gatherers from Scandinavia, one hunter whose remains were found in a cave in Luxembourg and an early farmer from Germany.

The hunters appear to have arrived in Europe thousands of years before the advent of agriculture, hunkered down in southern Europe during the Ice Age and then expanded during a period called the Mesolithic, when the ice sheets retreated from central and northern Europe.

They are very alike and their genetic profile is not a good match for any modern group of people, suggesting they were caught up in the farming wave of advance. However, their genes live on in modern Europeans, to a greater extent in the north-east than in the south.

'Start Quote

We can dissect these components in any modern European and explain diversity in modern Europeans as different proportions of these three populations'

End Quote Prof Carles Lalueza-Fox Institute of Evolutionary Biology (CSIC - UPF)

The genome from the remains of the early farmer found near Stuttgart showed a completely different pattern, however. Her genetic profile was a good match for modern people native to the Italian island of Sardinia, and was rather different from the indigenous hunters.

The Sardinians could represent a population of early farmers that became isolated on the Mediterranean island, and were little affected by later migrations that shaped the rest of Europe.

But, puzzlingly, while the early farmers share genetic similarities with Near Eastern people on a global scale, they are significantly different in other ways. Prof Reich suggests that more recent migrations in the farmers' 'homeland' may have diluted their genetic signal in that region today.

Prof Reich explained: 'In the end, the only way we'll be able to prove this is by getting ancient DNA samples along the potential trail from the Near East to Europe... and seeing if they genetically match these predictions or if they're different.

'Maybe they're different - that would be extremely interesting.'

These regions will be the most challenging to get ancient samples from, however, because DNA breaks down more readily in warmer climates.

Pigmentation genes carried by the hunters and farmers showed that, while the dark hair, brown eyes and pale skin of the early farmer from Stuttgart would be a familiar look to us, the hunter-gatherers would stand out if we saw them on the street today.

'It really does look like the indigenous West European hunter gatherers had this striking combination of dark skin and blue eyes that doesn't exist any more,' Prof Reich told BBC News.

Given that both the western hunters and the farmers had dark locks, how did the great diversity of hair colour in today's Europeans develop?

'There's an evolutionary argument about this - that light skin in Europe is biologically advantageous for people who farm, because you need to make vitamin D,' said David Reich.

'Hunters and gatherers get vitamin D through their food - because animals have a lot of it. But once you're farming, you don't get a lot of it, and once you switch to agriculture, there's strong natural selection to lighten your skin so that when it's hit by sunlight you can synthesise vitamin D.'

Dr Carles Lalueza-Fox, from the Institute of Evolutionary Biology (CSIC - UPF) in Barcelona, Spain, who was not involved with the research, told BBC News: 'If you look at all the reconstructions of Mesolithic people on the internet, they are always depicted as fair skinned. And the farmers are sometimes depicted as dark-skinned newcomers to Europe. This shows the opposite.'

When the researchers looked at 2,345 genomes from present day people, they found that a third population was needed to capture the modern genetic complexity of Europeans.

This additional 'tribe' is the most enigmatic and, surprisingly, seems to have been related to Native Americans.

Hints of this group surfaced in an analysis of European genomes two years ago. Dubbed Ancient North Eurasians, this group remained a 'ghost population' until 2013, when scientists published the genome of a 24,000-year-old boy buried near Lake Baikal in Siberia.

This individual had genetic similarities with both Europeans and indigenous Americans, but lacked the East Asian ancestry present in Siberia and the Americas today. The ghost had been seen.

The 8,000-year-old Scandinavian hunters already show some signs of mixture with this population, but the ancient hunter from Luxembourg and the farmer from Germany do not, implying that the third ancestral group was added to the general continental mix after farming was established in Europe.

Dr Lalueza-Fox commented: 'The interesting point is the idea that we can dissect these components in any modern European and explain diversity in modern Europeans as different proportions of these three populations.'

Follow Paul on Twitter.